5709 Westfield Ave,
Pennsauken Township, NJ 08110

1515 Market St Suite 1200-B
Philadelphia, PA 19110

Understanding Product Liability: Compensation and Claims Against Small Businesses in NJ & PA

small business product liability law and insurance NJ & PA

Navigating the realm of product liability is important for both small businesses and consumers within New Jersey and Pennsylvania. This legal framework serves not only as a safeguard for businesses, but also as a critical protection for consumers. For small enterprises, grasping the subtleties of product liability is essential to protect against potentially devastating financial claims. For consumers, it is about recognizing their rights and the available recourse if harmed by a defective product. In this blog, we will explore the vital aspects of product liability for small businesses in NJ & PA, discuss what this means for consumers injured by defective products, and detail how both parties can successfully manage the claims process. By understanding these crucial elements, businesses can prepare more effectively with the right small business product liability insurance, and injured consumers can pursue compensation with greater confidence.

Basics of Product Liability in NJ & PA

Product liability is a critical area of law that plays a significant role in consumer protection, especially in states like New Jersey and Pennsylvania. This legal concept holds manufacturers, distributors, and retailers accountable when a product defect causes harm to a consumer. In New Jersey, the legal framework for addressing these issues is defined in the New Jersey Product Liability Act, which outlines three primary theories under which a manufacturer can be held liable: defective design, manufacturing defects, or failure to warn. Similarly, Pennsylvania’s laws provide avenues for consumers to seek redress under similar circumstances, making sure that those harmed by defective products can pursue compensation.

Defective design in New Jersey is considered when a product’s risks outweigh the benefits to consumers, or when a safer alternative design was feasible but not used. For example, a landmark case in New Jersey involved a room fogger that exploded due to its highly flammable propellant—which could have been avoided, since a less flammable alternative was readily available for use. This situation highlights a perfect example of a potential design defect claim. In Pennsylvania, the principles are broadly similar, focusing on whether a product is inherently dangerous due to its design, making it unfit for its intended use.

Manufacturing defects, on the other hand, occur when a product deviates from its intended design specifications or performance standards. In some cases, this could be due to an error in the manufacturing process itself, such as using an incorrect or lower-quality material than specified. Both New Jersey and Pennsylvania laws require the plaintiff to prove that the product that caused the injury was not manufactured according to the intended design or standards. The necessity of a product liability lawyer becomes evident here, as these cases usually require detailed investigation and expert testimony to establish the presence of a defect and its link to the injuries sustained.

When and Why Small Businesses Need Product Liability Insurance

Understanding the necessity of product liability insurance is integral for small businesses to succeed, particularly those involved in creating, manufacturing, distributing, or selling products. This form of insurance plays a major role in safeguarding businesses against the financial repercussions of lawsuits resulting from injuries or damages caused by defective products. Whether a product fails due to a design flaw, a manufacturing error, or inadequate warnings, product liability insurance provides an indispensable financial safety net.

Product liability insurance covers a range of incidents that could possibly bankrupt a small business. For instance, if a product like a tool or a skin care product causes injury or illness, the legal and medical costs could add up rapidly. That’s why product liability insurance is so important, as it helps cover expenses like legal fees, compensatory damages, and medical bills. This insurance also extends to various types of defects, including design defects, manufacturing defects, marketing errors, and even cases of strict liability where injury occurs without proven negligence on the part of the business. This full coverage is crucial because a business can be held liable even if the product is used incorrectly by the customer.

Although product liability insurance can cover many of the costs associated with these types of claims, it does not cover all of it. Product liability insurance typically does not cover software-related issues, employee injuries, accidents involving customers on business premises, or product recall costs. Determining the appropriate amount of coverage is essential and depends on several factors, including the type of products sold, the volume of sales, the business’s location, and historical claims data. For businesses in industries with higher risks, such as food and beverages or children’s products, higher coverage limits are often recommended due to the increased likelihood of litigation.

Consumer Rights and Actions After Injury

When consumers in New Jersey or Pennsylvania are injured by a defective product from a small business, they are protected under robust product liability laws. These laws ensure that consumers can seek compensation if they have suffered due to design defects, manufacturing errors, or insufficient warnings. In both states, the legal framework allows for claims under theories such as strict liability, where the responsibility for harm can be established irrespective of the manufacturer’s negligence. This protection empowers consumers to hold small businesses accountable for the safety of the products they sell.

Understanding your rights is crucial. In New Jersey, for instance, if a consumer is injured by a product, they can pursue a claim based on defective design if they can demonstrate that the product’s design was inherently unsafe. Similarly, Pennsylvania consumers can assert claims for manufacturing defects if they can show that the product deviated from its intended design and that this deviation led to their injury. It is essential for injured consumers to promptly document the incident, seek medical attention, get possession of the defective product and a similar product if possible, and consult with a product liability lawyer in NJ or PA who can provide expertise on navigating these claims.

Filing a Product Liability Claim

Filing a product liability claim involves several key steps, starting with the immediate documentation of the incident. Consumers should report the accident to the business from where the product was purchased and ensure they obtain a written report. Photographic evidence of the accident scene and the defective product, along with witness testimonials, can significantly bolster a claim. It is also vital to preserve any physical evidence, such as the product itself and any packaging, which can be crucial in demonstrating the defect in court.

For a successful product liability claim in NJ or PA, the plaintiff must prove that the product was defective and that this defect directly caused their injury. This may involve demonstrating that the business knew of the potential hazard but failed to correct it or warn consumers adequately. Legal representation is crucial as product liability lawyers are adept at navigating these complex cases, including engaging expert witnesses who can testify about the product’s defects and the feasibility of safer alternatives. Engaging a skilled product liability attorney early in the process can help ensure that all procedural requirements are met, including adhering to the statute of limitations for filing claims.

Potential Compensation and Recoverable Damages

Once a product liability claim is established, the focus shifts to the compensation that the injured party can recover. In NJ and PA, damages in product liability cases may include past, present, and future medical expenses, lost wages, pain and suffering, and in severe cases, punitive damages intended to punish particularly egregious behavior by the defendant. The extent of these damages often depends on the nature of the injury and the impact on the victim’s life, highlighting the importance of comprehensive documentation and expert medical testimony in substantiating the claim.

It is also important to understand the concept of comparative negligence which both NJ and PA employ. Under this rule, if the injured party is found partially at fault for their injuries, their compensation may be reduced proportionally to their degree of fault. For instance, if a consumer is found to be 20% responsible for their injuries due to improper use of a product, their compensation will be reduced by that percentage. This emphasizes the need for clear and compelling evidence to minimize the fault attributed to the injured consumer, allowing them to maximize their recoverable damages.

When to Hire a Product Liability Lawyer

When injured by a defective product from a small business in New Jersey or Pennsylvania, one of the first steps should be consulting a product liability lawyer. This type of Experienced attorney can guide you through the complex legal landscape of product liability, solidifying that your rights are protected and that you receive the compensation you deserve. Product liability cases can be intricate, involving multiple parties from manufacturers to retailers, and they require an understanding of both specific state laws and the broader principles of products liability, including negligence, strict liability, and breach of warranty.

The Law Offices of Vincent J. Ciecka, serving both New Jersey and Pennsylvania, offer experienced legal representation in these cases, including a recent $20,000,000 recovery in a defective truck tire case.  Founded in 1976, our firm has a long-standing reputation for assisting over 11,000 accident victims, focusing on personal injury, motor vehicle accidents, catastrophic accident cases, workplace injuries, and specifically, product liability. Our approach as a ‘people’s practice’ makes sure that all clients receive compassionate, understanding service that demystifies the legal process while still focusing on achieving the best possible outcomes for their cases.

Determining the right time to engage a personal injury product liability lawyer involves several considerations. Immediately after an incident, it’s crucial to gather as much evidence as possible and to document the injury and the product condition. If the product that caused the injury was part of your regular use and was expected to be safe, and if your injury has resulted in medical expenses, loss of income, or long-term suffering, these are strong indicators that legal advice is necessary. The Law Offices of Vincent J. Ciecka are well-equipped to handle such cases, offering a deep understanding of the medical aspects of personal injuries and an extensive track record in maximizing claims and settlements. Our team includes former insurance company adjusters, which gives us unique insights into how insurers evaluate claims.

By engaging a product liability lawyer early, you can rest easy knowing that your case is being professionally handled from the start, allowing you to avoid common pitfalls such as missing critical deadlines under the statute of limitations or failing to adequately document the claim. If you find yourself or a loved one injured by a defective product, consider reaching out to The Law Offices of Vincent J. Ciecka to discuss your situation and explore your legal options.

Conclusion: Ensuring Justice and Fair Compensation in Product Liability Cases

Navigating the complexities of product liability can be daunting for both consumers and small business owners. For consumers in New Jersey and Pennsylvania who find themselves injured by defective products, it’s important to understand their rights and the appropriate steps to take if facing a potential product liability claim. Small businesses, on the other hand, must recognize the importance of having adequate product liability insurance to protect against potential lawsuits and financial losses

For injured consumers, knowing when to seek compensation and how to go about it effectively can make a significant difference in the outcome of their cases. Similarly, for small businesses, understanding the scope of product liability insurance and obtaining adequate coverage is essential for business continuity and financial stability. Whether you are a consumer who has suffered an injury or a small business striving to safeguard your operations, consulting with a knowledgeable product liability lawyer can provide the guidance and support needed to navigate these challenging waters.


  1. Lewis v. American Cyanamid Co., 715 A.2d 967 (N.J. 1998) – Supreme Court of New Jersey
  2. What is Product Liability Insurance For Small Business? – Forbes
  3. N.J. Stat. § 2A:58C-2 – Liability of manufacturer or seller in product liability action – Casetext
  4. SENATE BILL No. 784 Session of 1981 – The General Assembly of Pennsylvania

Contact Us

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.